All Natural Unicorn Toast Recipe — Sugar & Cloth Recipes (2024)

November 20, 2023July 10, 2017 by Ashley

We’re whipping up a toast pairing that’s as pretty as it is delicious with this all-natural unicorn toast recipe on the blog!

You know I’m a big fan of all things “unicorns,” as seen here, here, and here.

But to be totally honest, I’m slightly weirded out by eating overly colorful food items in a single sitting. (Unless it’s ice cream, I have low sugar standards.)

This is all weird coming from a self-proclaimed color fanatic (and possibly unicorn). Don’t you think?! Is anyone else with me on this?

A bite here and there… sure!A full-fledged color explosion snack? Not so much.

Hence why I’ve been wanting to jump on the unicorn toast trend but was hesitant until we came up with this all-natural unicorn toast recipe that’s actually tasty and not full of crazy food dyes.

We also made them usingThe Laughing Cow® Cheese (instead of the marshmallow fluff that they’re traditionally made with) and yummy cheese pairings for garnishes!

Ingredients Needed

The Laughing Cow® Creamy Swiss Cheese

Whole grain loaf of bread

All-natural food coloring or vegetable/fruit powders

Avocado slices, garnishes & pairings for taste

Mango garnishes & pairings for taste

Assorted berries garnishes & pairings for taste

Honey garnishes & pairings for taste

Salt and pepper garnishes & pairings for taste

The Laughing Cow® Creamy Original Swiss Cheese is the perfect base for making just about any sweet or savory combination you can dream up.

Of course, I’m all about the pretty presentation. But a creamy snack pairing is just as important!

As I mentioned in the recipe, you can use either all-natural food coloring or vegetable/fruit powders.

I thought the natural food coloring route was much easier for getting saturated colors while making the flavor pairings of the garnishes much easier to control.

I also really loved the look of the marbled food coloring in the cheese. Don’t you?!

How to Make All Natural Unicorns Toasts

Step 1 – Stir The Laughing Cow® Creamy Original Swiss Cheese wedges in a large bowl until blended and creamy.

Step 2 – Divide the cheese into separate bowls and add either all-natural, food-based food coloring or vegetable powders to each bowl to create the colors of your choice.

Step 3 – Toast the whole grain toast, and spread the cheese onto the slices in the color combinations of your choice.

Step 4 – When garnishing, keep in mind mixing savory items versus sweet. We paired avocado slices with salt, pepper, and spinach power; berries with sugared flower petals, honey, and dried fruit chips (either mango, coconut, or strawberry).

You can never go wrong with a good, pink marble-sweetened berries toast! Especially if they’re served on a plate full of these colorful babies, right?!

It can also be served with your favorite Dalgona coffee recipe

More Toasted Snacks to Try

Looking for more snacks to eat this holiday season? you might want to check out our related posts below –

• Whipped Ricotta Topped French Toast with Boozy Blood Orange Compote Recipe
• Toasted S’mores Rice Krispie Treats Recipe
• 6 Simple Insta-Worthy Toast Combos
• Toasted Marshmallow Ice Cream Shot Recipe
• Easy Sourdough French Toast Recipe

Don’t forget to share your unicorn toast with us on Instagram using the hashtag #sugarandclothloves. We always love seeing all of your creations! Looking for more quick and delicious recipes? Find them all right here, with a few desserts to go along with them!

A big thanks to our friends atThe Laughing Cow®for partnering with us on this post!Sugar & Cloth has chosen to donate 5% of all sponsored campaigns to charity, which you can read more about right here.